A by-election is being held in Mulgrave District on Saturday 18 November to elect a new member of Parliament, after the resignation of The Hon. Daniel Andrews.

Anyone enrolled to vote in Mulgrave District can vote from Wednesday 8 November to Saturday 18 November.

Assessment Difficulties

Vote Climate One’s assessment process is biased towards supporting independent candidates. We are convinced that the pathway to real climate action is via a progressive cross bench which holds the balance of power in the lower house where governments are formed. For independent candidates every vote is a conscience vote free of party pressures.

Two independents in Mulgrave have been ranked with a Red Light because they have failed to answer our questions. The aim of the questions is to determine how strongly they will vote on climate legislation. There was only one Orange Light candidate in this by-election. If you have any contact with these candidates please urge them to answer our assessment questions . This creates the opportunity of changing their Traffic Light Voting ranking. Contact Rob on 0427580803

It is important to note that the two major parties are not assessed on their climate policy per se. Our advice aims at reducing the seats held by either major party so that a progressive minority government can be elected. This in some cases may seem counter intuitive and the seat of Mulgrave is no exception. In Victoria the Labor party has a better climate policy than the Liberal/National coalition but in this case we have advised you to put the Liberal candidate ahead of Labor.

The Four Green Light Candidates

ACKERLY, Celeste

In the recent state election the Sustainable Australia Party was ranked by Vote Climate One as a Green Light Party because of their strong climate policy. We have no hesitation on continuing this advice for the Mulgrave by-election.

Cvetkova, Kelly

Climate change

The climate emergency is a dire threat to our natural environment, our water resources, our food supply and the liveability of our cities. Instead of funding adaptation, in the 2022 budget the Andrews government reduced climate change spending by 40 percent, to just $28 million. Victoria is one of the world’s largest per-capita emitters of greenhouse gases, but we also have the resources and skills to develop a renewable energy economy, which would revitalise the state’s dying manufacturing industry, and provide quality, skilled jobs for tens of thousands of people. Instead, Labor has lifted a ban on new gas development, opening the door to new projects that will lock in new fossil fuel emissions, damage local ecosystems and do nothing to arrest our current trajectory towards catastrophic climate change.

What we think

1. Climate change is a direct product of the capitalist world economy, which turns everything in the natural environment into a resource exploitable for private profits.
2. Climate change cannot be addressed through market mechanisms; it requires a comprehensive restructuring of the economy.
3. The high concentration of greenhouse gases already in the atmosphere means that “net-zero emissions” will not be enough to curtail dangerous global warming; net-negative emissions will be required to reduce greenhouse gas levels.
4. Nuclear power is neither clean nor renewable.
5. The effects of climate change are disproportionately felt by people on low incomes; their lives and livelihoods need to be protected not only from changes to the climate, but during the transition to a new economy.
6. The economic burden of dealing with climate change must fall primarily on those who have profited from destroying the environment: the rich and the big polluters.

What we’ll fight for

1. Reduce emissions by 75 percent below 2005 levels by 2030, achieve a zero-carbon economy by 2035 and a permanent net-negative emissions economy by 2040.
2. Phase out the use of coal and gas for electricity generation by 2030.
3. Reverse Labor’s lifting of the ban on new gas projects and prohibit the development of all new fossil fuel projects (including banning the proposed gas import terminals) and exports: Environmental approvals for new resource developments to be contingent on carbon-neutrality.
4. Stop the establishment of a nuclear power industry in the state.
5. Urgently construct solar and wind farms and upgrade the power grid with battery storage to enable the quick transition of Victorian homes and businesses to an all-electric, post-gas energy system. As part of this transition, all new housing and industrial developments must be all-electric, with no new gas connections.
6. Establish a renewables manufacturing industry (solar photovoltaic, lithium-ion battery and electric vehicles), with guaranteed secure jobs and retraining for workers from the fossil fuel industry.
7. Make 100 percent of all new car sales electric vehicles by 2030.
8. Establish 1,500 electric vehicle charging stations across Victoria by 2028.
9. Fund research into adaptation strategies to protect biodiversity, water resources and agricultural yields. 
10. Immediately end logging in native forests. This will protect habitats, water catchments, biodiversity and terrestrial carbon stores. Establish programs of reforestation and restoration of native grasslands and wetlands.
11. Adapt our cities to heat extremes by increasing urban tree canopy.
12. Repeal the Labor government’s anti-protest laws, which are being used to target opponents of environmental vandalism.

GARAD Rhonda

As a candidate standing for the Greens, Vote Climate One has ranked Rhonda with a Green Light. The Greens policy on climate is very strong. For action on climate reference Green Light candidates before Orange and Red.

CURRIE, Bronwyn

The Climate Emergency

The Animal Justice Party (AJP) is the only political party with policies that comprehensively take into account all sources of emissions, including the impact of animal agriculture and land clearing on the global climate, and the need to urgently transition to a plant-based diet in order to address the climate crisis.

The AJP will take urgent action to address the climate emergency. In addition to phasing out fossil fuels, we will transition from animal agriculture towards more sustainable plant-based farming, and transform other climate-threatening industries and practices. This is essential not only to reduce harmful emissions, but also to protect nature, and human and other animal life.

Key Objectives

1. Declare a climate emergency and biodiversity emergency at every level of government as the first step towards systemic change and climate justice.
2. Rapidly transition from animal agriculture to plant-based agriculture and promote plant-based diets (see our Human Diet and Animals Policy). 
3. Protect, regenerate, expand, rewild and enhance all ecological systems including forests, grasslands, freshwater and marine habitats, in part by reserving at least 50% of the planet for nature (see our Policies on Human Population, Land Clearing and Marine Animals).
4. Develop water management policies that are responsive to climate change and that prioritise animals, the environment and people over commercial interests (see our Water Management Policy).
5. Develop and fund comprehensive plans and actions to assist all animal species and vulnerable human populations to adapt to a changing climate.
6. Rapidly phase out fossil fuels and transition to clean energy infrastructure (see our Energy Policy).
7. Commit to ambitious emission reduction targets which do not encourage dead end ‘solutions’, such as natural gas (see our latest Election Platform).
8. Remove subsidies from the fossil fuel and animal agriculture industries in the interim and redirect funding into clean energy solutions and sustainable plant-based agriculture.
9. Shift away from road transport toward more environmentally-friendly modes, including rail and mass transit, together with walking and cycling (see our Land Transport Policy).
10. Reimagine urban design to be climate-friendly and climate-resilient, and incentivise research and development into net zero carbon building materials and practices. 

Background

The climate emergency is a planetary crisis requiring immediate and substantial action. It is caused by increased greenhouse gases in the atmosphere that cause the Earth’s temperature to rise, i.e., global heating. Moreover, global heating creates feedback loops, causing more carbon dioxide to be released, for example, through the thawing of permafrost. Human activity drives the increases in greenhouse gas emission, e.g., land clearing, animal agriculture and fossil fuel use, but also transport, and building and construction. Carbon dioxide is not the only greenhouse gas; methane, nitrous oxide and various fluorine gases are also contributors. 

Humans and other animals are already suffering from the impacts of the climate emergency. This emergency is driving species extinction, changes in weather and climatic extremes, changes in precipitation patterns and soil moisture, our ability to grow food, availability of and access to freshwater, and more. In Australia, for example, the climate emergency has already significantly impacted our water security. Entire social and technological systems will also feel the impact, such as our health systems and energy systems.  

Even when we stop emitting greenhouse gases, heating will continue for some decades. There is evidence that tipping points are near. Ultimately, the climate emergency is as much a threat to nature and our biological systems as it is a threat to our social and political systems worldwide. 

The imperative is for urgent action now to protect what we can, stop the emission of greenhouse gases, and accelerate ecological regeneration for climate protection.

Climate Justice

The brunt of the climate emergency will be borne disproportionately by socially and economically disadvantaged groups such as women and children, First Nations Peoples, younger generations and non-human animals. This is felt between and within nations, leading to ever greater inequalities. The AJP supports measures to alleviate these environmental and climate injustices.

With the growing number of climate refugees, the AJP will help Australia to fulfil its role as a good global citizen for those in need (see our Asylum Seeker Position). Many are already affected by the climate emergency in Australia and overseas, and we support speedy and effective measures for those suffering hardship.

To address the problem, we must offer support to people and businesses that want to transition away from exploiting animals and the environment, in particular those with significant climate footprints. Our Ethical Economy Policy calls for a transition to kind and meaningful employment for all Australians.

There is an important role for First Nations People and local communities in advising and taking leading roles in protecting and climate-proofing nature and local communities. We support governance and solutions that enable First Nations People to adopt these leadership roles (see our First Nations Position).   

Climate justice must include all species. AJP supports the reservation of at least 50% of the planet for nature (see our Human Population Policy), and calls for the regeneration of the natural world and adaptation strategies to assist animals facing a changing climate. Ultimately, this will create a more resilient and healthier world for all of us.

Regeneration and Protection of Nature

Our survival and the survival of other species depends on a healthy environment. However, major crises are threatening life on Earth: the climate emergency, biodiversity emergency, and emerging diseases. These crises are connected. An important part of the solution is the protection and regeneration of nature, enabled by a shift to a plant-based diet (see below in the Animal Agriculture section). Our vision includes natural and assisted regeneration, such as rewilding current agricultural lands, planting trees, improving biodiversity in parks and cities, and rehabilitating former mining sites, other land and waterways.

The United Nations Global Biodiversity Outlook 5 identifies eight critical transitions that are required to shift to a “sustainable coexistence with nature”. One transition is focused on the climate emergency, while agriculture is directly or indirectly implicated in most of these transitions. That is why AJP specifically focuses on animal agriculture in this policy.

Fossil Fuels

The burning of fossil fuels is not the only source of carbon dioxide pollution, but it is the largest. Fossil fuels are also used directly to provide carbon for steel, plastic and chemical production. In cold climates, fossil fuels are the major source of direct heating; and in all climates the major source of energy for transport (see our Land Transport Policy). 

Global agreements to limit fossil fuels have only slowed the rate of increase. Between 2015 and 2019 there was a global increase in the use of coal (by 7.6%), oil (by 5%) and gas (by 15%). 

Rather than using and exporting fossil fuels, Australia must develop clean industrial and energy infrastructure and export those technologies to the world. The AJP is committed to rapidly phasing out fossil fuels, supporting innovation, and transitioning to clean energy infrastructure.

Animal Agriculture and Food Choices

Animal agriculture is a major contributor to the climate crisis, and yet, it is too often overlooked or ignored by climate advocates and major political parties. In Australia, agriculture contributes around 13% of our greenhouse gas emissions each year without considering the effects of land-clearing. However, that 13% is misleading: methane emitted by animal agriculture has a much greater heating effect than the carbon dioxide emitted from burning fossil fuels.

The following chart, using Australia’s 2021 UN Inventory data, shows that methane emissions from Australia’s 28 million cows and 70 million sheep will have more impact on the climate in the next 20 years (GWP20) than all of our coal or gas-fired electricity power stations combined (Figure 1).

If global trends in meat and dairy intake continue, global mean temperature rise will more than likely exceed 2 degrees Celsius, even with an instantaneous cessation of fossil fuel use. Climate solutions must tackle both carbon dioxide and methane levels simultaneously.

For a truly sustainable, equitable and food-secure future, global organisations are now calling on governments to commit to a reduction in or moratoriums on animal agriculture and positive support for plant-based diets, including 

• Food and Agriculture Organisation (FAO); 
• Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC);
• Intergovernmental Science-Policy Platform on Biodiversity and Ecosystems Services (IPBS);
• United Nations Convention on Biological Diversity;
• The Alliance of World Scientists; and 
• World Animal Protection. 

This transition will invariably require government support to assist businesses and workers currently working in animal agriculture to re-train and transition into more sustainable and humane plant-based industries, including emerging industries in plant-based alternatives (e.g., alternative milks and proteins), as well as cell-based meats. These types of TransFARMation projects are already taking place successfully around the world. Major meat producers are adopting plant-based products in an effort to meet consumer demand and protect their bottom line. 

Australian governments, other Australian political parties and the animal agriculture industry fail to recognise animal agriculture as part of the problem. They propose ineffective responses to this problem. For example, feeding cows red seaweed makes headlines but only covers 10% of their lifetime emissions, has serious animal welfare implications, is impractical to scale commercially, and fails to address land clearing.

Building and Urban Design

New homes in Australia are among the largest in the world; particularly free-standing houses. Large houses use more materials to build and furnish, and more energy to run. All material goods begin either as the output of mines, forests, cropping, or animal agriculture. Housing materials and contents frequently generate emissions not just via energy used in mining and processing, but also via the chemistry of manufacture. Cement, for example, not only uses prodigious amounts of energy during production, but the process itself generates carbon dioxide. Global cement production is about 4.4 billion tonnes per year; generating about 2.6 billion tonnes of carbon dioxide. We desperately need a climate-friendly alternative. 

It is not just the homes and buildings we need to change, but the cities and townscapes around them. Cities are major sources of emissions. We must mitigate climate change by stopping urban sprawl and developing walkable cities (see our Human Population & Planning and Land Transport Policies). Australia must also adapt to climate change by welcoming nature back into our suburbs (see our Urban Animals Policy) and making our towns and cities cooler with better designs, less concrete and more green spaces. Implementing biodiversity-sensitive urban design (BSUD) creates settlements that support the local ecosystem rather than replace it. It is positive all round: cities are cooler and emit less, people are happier and more active, and species become more resilient to a changing climate and landscape.

Climate Targets

The AJP wants to see Australia’s emissions plummet but cautions against interim measures which may risk entrenching the fossil fuel and animal agriculture industries. For example, switching from coal to gas and offshoring emission intensive industries has provided short-term ‘good news’ for domestic audiences but may do more harm than good in the long run. Targets in the fossil fuel industry must mean transitioning to clean energy; not investing in trying to make fossil fuels ‘cleaner’. Likewise, targets in animal agriculture must mean transitioning towards sustainable plant-based agriculture; not ‘greenwashing’ suggestions like feeding cows seaweed (see above).